Mountain Conference
1996- Lancaster Linemen
1997- Lancaster Linemen
1998- Whodat? Tornadoes
1999- Whodat? Tornadoes
2000- Fighting Bass
2001- Arizona Dust Devils
2002- Fighting Bass
2003- Arizona Dust Devils
2004- Whodat? Tornadoes
2005- Whodat? Tornadoes
2006- Whodat? Tornadoes
2007- Vienna Vengeance
2008- Vienna Vengeance
2009- Fighting Bass
2010- Vienna Vengeance
2011- Vienna Vengeance

Piedmont Conference
1996- Deerwood Huddle
1997- Peoria Panthers
1998- Lewisville Tarbillies
1999- Lewisville Tarbillies
2000- Lewisville Tarbillies
2001- Lewisville Tarbillies
2002- Carolina Huddle
2003- Lewisville Tarbillies
2004- Peoria Panthers
2005- Peoria Panthers
2006- Peoria Panthers
2007- On Tilt
2008- Mighty Mulligans
2009- On Tilt
2010- Peoria Panthers
2011- Phoenix Phantoms

Coastal Conference
1997- Robin Roosters
1998- Shane's Untouchables
1999- Robin Roosters
2000- Robin Roosters
2001- Shane's Untouchables
2002- Robin Roosters
2003- Bootleggers
2004- Robin Roosters
2005- Shane's Untouchables
2006- BK's Broilers
2007- BK's Broilers
2008- BK's Broilers
2009- Kelley's Heroes
2010- Kelley's Heroes
2011- Shane's Untouchables

Super Bowls
I 1996- Deerwood Huddle
II 1997- Deerwood Huddle
III 1998- Bootleggers
IV 1999- Arizona Dust Devils
V 2000- Robin Roosters
VI 2001- Lewisville Tarbillies
VII 2002- Robin Roosters
VIII 2003- Arizona Dust Devils
IX 2004- Peoria Panthers
X 2005- Whodat? Tornadoes
XI 2006- BK's Broilers
XII 2007- On Tilt
XIII 2008- Whodat? Tornadoes
XIV 2009- High Voltage
XV 2010- Kelley's Heroes